Category: Regulatory Compliance
Regulatory compliance is the work of making an organisation’s own rules sound in law and applying them correctly to the cases that arise. This section covers the practical building blocks for governing bodies, professional bodies and membership organisations: reviewing rules against statute and the common law, keeping a rules register, making and amending rules with proper authority, and applying them fairly to disciplinary, eligibility and safeguarding cases – including how the rules should deal with emerging issues such as AI. It is written for boards, panel chairs, case officers and secretariats, much of it drawn from practice in sport. If you need support putting any of this into practice, see our Regulatory Compliance advisory services.
Should a Disciplinary Appeal Be a Rehearing or a Review?
The single most important design choice in an appeals procedure is whether the appeal body starts again or reviews what went before. Here’s how the two models differ, and how to choose.
What Standard of Proof Applies in Sports Disciplinary Proceedings?
Most sports disciplinary cases are decided on the balance of probabilities, but not all, and the rules do not always say which. Here’s the default position, the anti-doping exception, and why the rules should state the standard expressly.
Who Can Sit on a Disciplinary or Appeal Panel?
Bias is one of the most common grounds of challenge to sports and professional body decisions. Here’s the legal test, the situations that most often cause problems, and how to constitute a panel that will stand.
What Should a Disciplinary Panel’s Written Reasons Contain?
Reasons are where a disciplinary decision is won or lost on appeal. Here’s what a panel’s written decision needs to contain, and the common faults that leave sound decisions exposed.
Can a Governing Body Suspend a Member While a Complaint Is Investigated?
Interim suspension pending investigation is one of the most consequential decisions a governing body takes, and one of the most often challenged. Here’s when it is justified and how to do it properly.
How Should a Governing Body Apply Its Rules to a Live Case?
Applying rules to a live case means establishing jurisdiction, identifying the right version of the rule, following the procedure, and reaching a reasoned, fair decision. Here’s what each step involves and what to do when something goes wrong.
Who Should Approve a Change to an Organisation’s Rules?
A rule change is only as good as the authority behind it. Here’s who should be able to make which rules, what approval should check, and what needs to happen once a change is made.
What Should a Rules Register Actually Record?
A rules register is a single, authoritative record of every rule an organisation has made, which version is in force, and where its authority comes from. Here’s what it should record and how to build one.
How to Review an Organisation’s Rules Against Statute and Common Law
A rules review tests a governing body’s constitution, regulations and procedures against statute, the common law and its own governing document. Here’s when to do one, what it should test, and what should come out of it.
Do Your Organisation’s Rules Cover the Use of AI?
Most governing bodies’ and professional bodies’ rules say nothing about AI, and that silence is starting to matter in conduct, evidence and disciplinary cases. Here’s where AI shows up in a rulebook and what to change.
AI Is a Compliance Question, Not a Technology Question
Much of what has been sold as “AI governance” is old law in new packaging. The obligations that bite on AI use are the ones organisations already have, and the answer lies in doing existing compliance properly.