How Should a Governing Body Apply Its Rules to a Live Case?

Applying a rule to a live case means establishing jurisdiction, identifying the version of the rule that applied at the time, following the procedure the rules prescribe, and reaching a reasoned decision through a process that is fair as a whole. Most successful challenges to the decisions of governing bodies turn not on whether the outcome was right, but on whether one of those steps was missed.

Does the body have jurisdiction?

The first question is whether the person is bound by the rules at all, and whether the conduct falls within them. A lapsed membership, registration through a club rather than directly, an official who was never formally appointed, conduct that took place before a rule came into force or outside the activities the rules govern: each of these can defeat a case before it begins. It is far better to establish jurisdiction at the outset, in writing, than to have it raised for the first time on appeal.

Which version of the rule applies?

Rules change, and the version in force when the conduct occurred will usually govern the substance of the case, even where a newer procedure is used to hear it. This is where a well-kept rules register earns its keep; without one, panels are too often working from whichever copy happens to be on the website.

What does a fair process require?

Where a body’s rules bind its members by contract, the courts will not review its decisions by way of judicial review (R v Disciplinary Committee of the Jockey Club, ex parte Aga Khan [1993] 1 WLR 909), but they will supervise them in private law, and the body is expected to act fairly and in accordance with its own rules. In practice, that means:

  • Notice – the person knows the case against them, and the evidence it rests on, in time to answer it
  • An opportunity to be heard – in writing or in person, as the rules and the seriousness of the matter require
  • An unbiased decision-maker – no one sits who has prejudged the case, has a personal interest in it, or was involved in bringing it
  • A decision within the rules – the panel applies the rule as it is written, not as it wishes it had been written
  • Reasons – enough to show the person why the decision was reached, and to allow an appeal to engage with it
  • A proportionate outcome – a sanction tailored to the case, particularly where it bears on a person’s ability to work or compete (Bradley v Jockey Club [2005] EWCA Civ 1056)

What if something has already gone wrong?

Errors happen, and the rules should anticipate them. In Modahl v British Athletic Federation [2001] EWCA Civ 1447 the Court of Appeal looked at whether the disciplinary process, taken as a whole and including the appeal, had been fair, which is a useful reminder that a properly constituted appeal can put right a defect at first instance. It is not a licence to be careless at the first stage, since an appeal that merely rubber-stamps a flawed decision cures nothing. Where an error is spotted before a decision is final, the better course is usually to acknowledge it, pause, and correct it, recording what was done and why.

Case files are also full of personal, and often special category, data, so where information has been mishandled along the way, the organisation’s data breach procedure may need to run alongside the case itself.

If you’d like support on a live case, or with the procedures that govern them, see our Regulatory Compliance advisory services.