black and white metal frame

Regulatory Compliance

Regulatory compliance, as we practise it, is the work of making an organisation’s own rules do what they are meant to do: made with proper authority, consistent with statute and the common law, and applied fairly and correctly to the situations that actually arise. IOLIS advises national governing bodies, professional bodies, umbrella and federated bodies, and membership organisations on their constitutions, regulations, codes and procedures, and on the decisions taken under them, with particular depth in sport.

What does regulatory compliance involve?

Every governing body or professional body runs on a set of rules, a constitution or articles at the top, then the regulations, bylaws, codes of conduct and procedures made under them, covering membership, eligibility, licensing, discipline, safeguarding, selection, complaints and appeals. The work divides, broadly, into two halves: making sure the rules themselves are sound, and making sure they are applied properly when a case comes along, which is where most of the difficulty, and most of the legal exposure, tends to sit.

Our support typically includes:

  • Rules reviews, testing constitutions, regulations and procedures against statute, the common law and the organisation’s own governing document
  • Rules registers and rulebook consolidation, so that the organisation can say which version of which rule was in force on any given date
  • Rule-making and amendment procedures, so that changes are made by the right body, in the right way, and actually bind those they are meant to bind
  • Advice on live cases for case officers, panel chairs and secretariats, on jurisdiction, procedure, fairness, sanctions and reasons
  • Disciplinary, safeguarding and complaints procedures, drafted or rewritten so that volunteers and staff can follow them and they hold up on appeal
  • Independent review of decisions already taken, where a board needs to know whether a decision is defensible before it is challenged
  • Panel and decision-maker support, including written guidance, procedural directions and training for those who sit on hearings
  • Emerging issues, including how the rules deal with the use of AI by members, officials and panels

Why does the law reach into an organisation’s own rules?

Because the rules of a membership body are, in essence, a contract between the body and its members, and the courts will hold the body to them. Sports governing bodies have been held not to be amenable to judicial review (R v Disciplinary Committee of the Jockey Club, ex parte Aga Khan [1993] 1 WLR 909), but that has never placed them beyond the reach of the courts: their decisions are supervised in private law, for lawfulness, fairness and, where a sanction bears on a person’s livelihood, proportionality, as the Court of Appeal confirmed in Bradley v Jockey Club [2005] EWCA Civ 1056.

Statute sits on top of that, from the Equality Act 2010, which applies to associations and to those who confer qualifications, to data protection law and the safeguarding framework. Rules that were drafted years ago, and amended piecemeal since, rarely keep pace with all of it, and the gaps tend to be found by the member who is challenging a decision rather than by the body that made it.

Who this is for

This support is aimed at national governing bodies of sport and their regional and club structures, professional and qualifying bodies, umbrella and federated organisations, and membership charities, together with the boards, panels, case officers and secretariats who make and apply their rules. Much of our work is in sport, where disciplinary, eligibility and safeguarding decisions are frequent, consequential and often taken by volunteers, but the same principles run through any body that regulates its members.

Our style of support

We start from the text of the rules and the operative law, not from a template, and we read the rules the way a challenger would, which is rarely the way their drafters intended. Advice is written to be used, by the people who have to apply it, often under time pressure and in the middle of a case.

Our advice is independent, tied to no vendor and sitting outside the internal politics that tend to surround contested decisions, which matters most when the honest answer is that a rule, or a decision already taken, will not survive challenge.

Talk to us

If your organisation is reviewing its rules, dealing with a difficult case, or rebuilding its disciplinary or appeals procedures, we would be happy to discuss what support would be most useful. Find the best way to contact us here.

We also provide separate Data Protection advisory services, including DPO support, DPIAs and subject access request support.