How to Review an Organisation’s Rules Against Statute and Common Law

A rules review tests an organisation’s constitution, regulations and procedures against the law that sits above them – statute, the common law, and the organisation’s own governing document – and identifies what needs to change before a case exposes the problem. For governing bodies and professional bodies, whose rules bind their members by contract and are tested with increasing regularity before courts and tribunals, it is the most useful piece of preventive work there is.

When should a rules review be carried out?

Periodically, on a cycle of no more than a few years, and in any event when the legal ground shifts beneath the rules, after a significant case or appeal, on a change of structure or membership model, or when an external requirement the rules implement, such as a funder’s code or an international federation’s regulations, is revised. The depth of review should scale with consequence: a rule about the colour of club kit needs rather less scrutiny than one that allows the organisation to suspend a member’s licence to coach or compete.

What does the review need to test?

A thorough review typically works through:

  • Vires – whether each rule was made by a body with power to make it, and under the procedure the constitution requires
  • Internal consistency – whether rules contradict one another, cross-refer to provisions that no longer exist, or leave gaps where no rule applies at all
  • Natural justice – whether disciplinary and decision-making procedures give the person affected notice of the case, a fair opportunity to answer it, and a decision-maker free of bias, requirements the courts have long read into the rules of domestic bodies (Russell v Duke of Norfolk [1949] 1 All ER 109)
  • Restraint of trade and the right to work – whether rules that restrict a person’s ability to earn a living, through licensing, eligibility or sanctions, are reasonable and no wider than they need to be, following the line of authority from Nagle v Feilden [1966] 2 QB 633
  • Proportionality of sanctions – whether the sanctions framework lets a panel tailor the outcome to the case, since the courts will review whether a penalty that bears on a person’s livelihood was proportionate (Bradley v Jockey Club [2005] EWCA Civ 1056)
  • Statutory overlay – the Equality Act 2010 provisions on associations and qualifications bodies, data protection law for the handling of case material, and the safeguarding framework
  • Workability – whether the people who must apply the rules, very often volunteers, can actually follow them

Who should be involved?

Whoever owns the rules at board or council level, the people who apply them day to day (case officers, panel chairs, the secretariat), and someone independent of both who can read the rules as a challenger would. That last perspective is the one most often missing, since those who drafted a rule tend to read into it what they meant, rather than what it actually says.

What happens with the output of the review?

The review should end in decisions, not just findings: rules to amend, rules to repeal, procedures to rewrite, and the order in which to do it, bearing in mind that some changes will need a general meeting and others can be made by the board. Each change then runs through the organisation’s proper rule-making process, and the rules register is updated, so that the results of the review do not quietly decay.

If you’d like support reviewing your organisation’s rules, see our Regulatory Compliance advisory services.