A change to an organisation’s rules is only as good as the authority behind it: it must be made by the body the constitution empowers to make it, through the procedure the constitution prescribes, and recorded so that anyone can later see when and how it happened. Get that wrong and the change may simply be invalid, which has a habit of being discovered at the worst possible moment, in the middle of a case that depends on it.
Why does the approval route matter so much?
Members of a governing body or professional body are bound by its rules because they have agreed to be, and what they have agreed to is the rules as made in accordance with the constitution. A rule adopted by a committee that had no power to adopt it, or by a board that skipped the required notice, binds no one, however sensible its content. Decisions taken under a defective rule are exposed to challenge on that ground alone, before anyone has looked at the merits.
Who should have authority to make which rules?
This should scale with consequence, and the constitution should say so plainly. Changes to the constitution itself typically require a special resolution of the members. Regulations that define membership, eligibility, discipline and sanctions are usually reserved to the board or council, sometimes with a duty to consult first. Operational procedures and guidance can often be delegated to a committee or to staff, provided the delegation is express and the delegated body cannot quietly expand its own remit. Where the constitution is silent or ambiguous about who may make a particular kind of rule, that silence is itself something to fix.
What should approval actually check?
- Is there a power to make this rule, and does this body hold it?
- Has the constitutional procedure been followed – notice, consultation, quorum and voting threshold?
- Has the rule been reviewed against statute and the common law, rather than simply drafted?
- Is it consistent with the rules around it, and have cross-references been updated?
- When does it take effect, and what happens to cases already under way?
- Has it been added to the rules register and published to those it binds?
What happens after approval?
Approval is not the end of the matter. Members and officials need to be told, the published version needs to match the adopted version exactly, and the rule needs a review date rather than an open-ended life. Transitional arrangements deserve particular care, since changing a disciplinary procedure part-way through a case, or applying a new rule to conduct that took place under the old one, is one of the more common ways a well-intentioned amendment produces an unfair outcome, and a live case that has to be unpicked.
If you’d like help designing rule-making and amendment procedures, see our Regulatory Compliance advisory services.