What Standard of Proof Applies in Sports Disciplinary Proceedings?

Unless the rules say otherwise, sports and other domestic disciplinary proceedings are decided on the civil standard, the balance of probabilities, and the seriousness of the allegation does not raise that standard. The House of Lords made the point plainly in Re B (Children) [2008] UKHL 35: there is one civil standard, and while the inherent probabilities may be relevant to deciding whether something happened, the standard itself does not shift.

What does the civil standard mean in practice?

That the panel must be satisfied that it is more likely than not that the alleged conduct occurred. It does not require certainty, and it does not require the panel to be sure in the criminal sense. Where an allegation is serious, a panel will rightly look carefully at the evidence, and may consider that serious misconduct is, on the facts, less inherently likely than minor misconduct, but that is a question of how the evidence is weighed rather than a higher bar.

Where is the standard different?

The main exception is anti-doping. The World Anti-Doping Code, implemented in the UK through the national anti-doping rules, requires an anti-doping organisation to establish a violation to the comfortable satisfaction of the hearing panel, a standard greater than a mere balance of probability but less than proof beyond reasonable doubt. Some governing bodies have borrowed that formulation for other integrity offences, such as match-fixing, and some rules still refer, often unthinkingly, to a criminal standard for particular charges. Where a different standard applies, it applies because the rules adopt it.

Why should the rules say so expressly?

  • Certainty – panels, many of them volunteers, should not have to work out the standard from first principles
  • Consistency – different panels applying different standards to similar cases is an obvious ground of challenge
  • Clarity about the burden – who has to prove what, including where the rules reverse the burden for particular defences
  • Avoiding drift – rules that are silent invite parties to argue for a higher standard in serious cases, which is precisely what Re B rejects

What should the panel record?

The standard it applied, stated in terms, and how it applied it to the disputed facts. A decision that never mentions the standard of proof, or that uses language suggesting a criminal standard when the rules require a civil one, is exposed on appeal however sound its conclusion. It is one of the simplest things to get right in written reasons, and one of the most frequently missed. A rules review is a good moment to settle the question once, in the rules, for every kind of case.

If you’d like help settling the standard and burden of proof in your rules, see our Regulatory Compliance advisory services.