What Should a Disciplinary Panel’s Written Reasons Contain?

A disciplinary panel’s written reasons should set out the facts it found, the rule it applied, how it dealt with the main points of evidence and argument, and why it reached the outcome and sanction it did, in enough detail that the person affected can understand why they won or lost and an appeal body can see whether the panel went wrong. Reasons do not need to be long, but they do need to show the working.

Why do reasons matter so much?

Because they are usually the only record of how the panel thought. An appeal body, or a court asked to supervise the decision, cannot look inside the panel’s deliberations; it can only look at what was written down. A decision that was entirely sound but poorly reasoned is exposed in a way that a well-reasoned decision is not, and the first ground of most appeals is, in one form or another, that the panel failed to explain itself. Reasons are also, more simply, part of a fair process: a person who has been sanctioned is entitled to know why.

What should the reasons contain?

  • The charge and the rule – the precise provision alleged to have been breached, in the version in force at the time
  • Jurisdiction – a short confirmation that the person was bound by the rules and the conduct fell within them
  • The standard of proof applied – stated, not assumed
  • Findings of fact – what the panel found happened, distinguishing what was agreed from what was disputed
  • The main evidential conflicts – where witnesses disagreed, whose account was preferred and why
  • Application of the rule to the facts – why the facts found do, or do not, amount to a breach
  • Sanction – the range available, the aggravating and mitigating factors considered, and why this outcome is proportionate
  • Rights of appeal – how, to whom and by when

What are the common faults?

The commonest is simply restating the evidence and then announcing a conclusion, without explaining how one led to the other. Close behind are failing to deal with a significant argument the person actually made, applying a rule without saying which one or in which version, and giving no reasons at all for the choice of sanction, which is often the part of the decision that matters most to the person concerned. Reasons that read as though they were written to justify a conclusion already reached, rather than to explain how it was reached, tend to invite exactly the challenge they were meant to prevent.

Who should write them, and when?

The panel, or its chair, ideally with support from an independent secretary or legal adviser, and as soon after the hearing as possible, while the evidence is fresh. Some bodies issue a short decision on the day with full reasons to follow, which is sensible provided the full reasons genuinely follow, within a period the rules specify. A template helps volunteers enormously, and is one of the more useful outputs of a rules review.

If you’d like help with reasons templates, panel guidance or a review of a decision, see our Regulatory Compliance advisory services.