Can a Subject Access Request Be Used to Get Disciplinary Evidence?

—

by

in

,

Yes: a person facing, or who has been through, a disciplinary or safeguarding process is entitled to make a subject access request, and the fact that they want the information to help with their case does not, of itself, make the request invalid. The Court of Appeal in Dawson-Damer v Taylor Wessing [2017] EWCA Civ 74 rejected the idea that a request made for a collateral purpose, such as litigation, could simply be refused on that ground, and organisations should plan on that basis rather than hope to resist requests because of why they were made.

What is the person entitled to?

Their own personal data, not the case file as such. Much of a disciplinary file will be the requester’s personal data, the allegations, the statements about them, the panel’s deliberations about them, but some of it will not, and some will be mixed with the personal data of complainants and witnesses. Since the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, the right of access is also expressly limited to the personal data found on a reasonable and proportionate search, which codifies what the courts had already said and gives organisations a clearer footing for scoping the exercise, though not a licence for a cursory one.

How is third-party information handled?

Carefully, and case by case. The Data Protection Act 2018 allows information identifying another person to be withheld unless that person consents or it is reasonable to disclose without consent, taking into account factors such as any duty of confidentiality, the steps taken to seek consent, and whether the person has refused. In disciplinary cases the requester will often already know who the complainant is, which bears on the assessment, but safeguarding cases can call for a much more protective approach. The answer is usually redaction rather than wholesale withholding, and the reasoning for each significant redaction should be recorded.

Are there other exemptions to consider?

  • Legal professional privilege – advice from lawyers on the case, though not the underlying facts
  • Management information and negotiations – in limited circumstances
  • Crime and taxation – where disclosure would be likely to prejudice the prevention or detection of crime, for example where a police investigation is running in parallel
  • Confidential references – given by the organisation itself

Each must be applied to specific material, not claimed for the file as a whole, and none is a general exemption for “documents relating to an ongoing case”.

What about timing?

A request does not pause the disciplinary process, and the disciplinary process does not pause the request; both run on their own clocks. In practice, the best approach is often to align the two: if the organisation will be disclosing evidence to the person for the hearing in any event, that disclosure can form part of the response, with the subject access response picking up what the hearing bundle does not. Where the volume or sensitivity is beyond in-house capacity, that is precisely the kind of request our subject access request support is designed for.

If you’d like advice on a subject access request arising from a case, see our Data Protection advisory services.