Who Can Sit on a Disciplinary or Appeal Panel?

Anyone the rules permit, provided they are not actually biased and a fair-minded and informed observer would not conclude that there was a real possibility that they were. That is the test for apparent bias set by the House of Lords in Porter v Magill [2001] UKHL 67, and it is the one most often tripped over by governing bodies, where everyone tends to know everyone and the pool of willing volunteers is small.

Why does apparent bias matter if no one was actually biased?

Because the test looks at appearances, not at the honest state of mind of the panel member. A panellist who is entirely open-minded can still disqualify themselves, and the panel’s decision, if the circumstances would lead an informed observer to see a real possibility of bias. The question is not whether they were fair but whether the process looked fair to someone who knew the relevant facts, and the courts have consistently treated that as an essential part of a fair hearing.

What situations most often cause problems?

  • Prior involvement – sitting on the panel having investigated the complaint, brought the charge or taken the interim suspension decision
  • Sitting on both stages – hearing the appeal from a decision the panellist helped make
  • Club and personal connections – belonging to the same club or rival club as a party, or a close personal or professional relationship
  • Expressed views – public comment, including on social media, about the case or the person
  • Institutional interest – a board member sitting on a case in which the board has a direct stake, such as a dispute over its own decision

Can a conflict be cured by disclosure?

Sometimes. A minor connection, disclosed at the outset and not objected to by the parties, may be acceptable, and the rules should provide a procedure for doing exactly that. But disclosure does not cure a disqualifying interest, and a party’s silence in the face of a disclosure made in a hurry, at the start of a hearing, without time to take advice, is a weak foundation on which to rest a decision. The safer course, where there is any real doubt, is to stand down.

How should a panel be constituted?

From a standing pool, ideally with at least one member independent of the body altogether, appointed by someone other than the person bringing the case, with conflicts declared in writing before the papers are sent out. The rules should separate the investigating, charging and deciding functions, and should prevent anyone who sat at first instance from sitting on the appeal. Where the pool is genuinely too small for that, an external panel or a service such as an independent sports tribunal is often worth the cost, and the point is a natural one to address in a rules review. An appeal heard by a properly independent body may also, as the Court of Appeal recognised in Modahl, put right a defect at first instance.

If you’d like help building a panel structure or advice on a conflict in a live case, see our Regulatory Compliance advisory services.