UK GDPR does not set retention periods for disciplinary or safeguarding records; it requires that personal data is kept no longer than is necessary for the purposes for which it is processed, and that the organisation can justify the period it has chosen. That is the storage limitation principle in Article 5(1)(e), and for case files, which are full of allegations, health information and sometimes criminal offence data, getting the period right matters in both directions: keep too much for too long and the organisation is exposed, delete too soon and it may be unable to defend a decision or protect someone at risk.
Why is there no single answer?
Because the purpose drives the period, and case files serve several purposes at once. A disciplinary record may need to be kept to show that a sanction was properly imposed, to deal with any appeal or legal claim, to apply rules about repeat conduct, and, in sport, to administer bans that run for years. A safeguarding record may need to be kept for far longer still, because concerns about an individual can take years to form a pattern, and because those affected may come forward long after the event.
How should the periods be set?
- Identify each purpose – defending the decision, administering a sanction, safeguarding, statistical reporting
- Attach a trigger to each – the end of an appeal window, the expiry of a sanction, the limitation period for a likely claim
- Distinguish outcomes – an unfounded or malicious allegation does not usually justify the same retention as a proven one, though the fact that an allegation was made and investigated may still need recording
- Separate the core record from the bulk – the decision, the reasons and the sanction may need to be kept long after witness statements and working papers can safely go
- Record the reasoning – in a retention schedule that names the trigger and the justification, rather than a bare number of years
What about safeguarding files?
These are the hardest case. Long retention is often justified, and statutory and inquiry guidance in the safeguarding field has repeatedly warned against premature destruction, but “keep everything forever” is not a retention policy. The better approach is to keep safeguarding records for a long, defined period with a documented rationale, to restrict access tightly, and to review rather than automatically extend. Safeguarding information will frequently be special category or criminal offence data, which brings its own conditions for processing and an expectation of an appropriate policy document covering retention.
What happens when a file is requested?
Retention decisions are tested most sharply when a subject access request arrives, often from someone who has just been through a disciplinary process. Material that should have been deleted under the organisation’s own schedule, but was not, must still be considered for disclosure, which is an uncomfortable position to explain. A schedule that is actually followed is, among other things, the best protection against that.
If you’d like help building a retention schedule for case records, see our Data Protection advisory services.