Should a Disciplinary Appeal Be a Rehearing or a Review?

An appeal can either rehear the case afresh, with the appeal body reaching its own decision on the evidence, or review the first decision, interfering only where it was wrong in law, procedurally unfair, unreasonable or disproportionate. Neither model is inherently better, but the rules must say clearly which one applies, because the answer determines what the appeal body is allowed to do and what an appellant has to show.

How does a rehearing work?

The appeal body hears the case again, usually with the evidence called afresh, and substitutes its own view for that of the first panel. It is the more protective model for the person appealing, and it has a significant practical advantage: a full and fair rehearing by an independent body can put right defects in the first hearing, which is the point the Court of Appeal drew out in Modahl v British Athletic Federation [2001] EWCA Civ 1447. The cost is time, expense and the burden on witnesses, who may be asked to give evidence twice.

How does a review work?

The appeal body looks at the first decision and asks whether it should stand, without rehearing the evidence. It will typically allow an appeal only on defined grounds, such as:

  • Error of law or misinterpretation of the rules
  • Procedural unfairness – including bias or a failure to let a party put their case
  • A decision no reasonable panel could have reached on the evidence
  • A disproportionate sanction
  • Fresh evidence – that was not reasonably available at the first hearing and might have made a difference

Reviews are quicker and cheaper, and respect the first panel’s advantage of having seen the witnesses, but they place more weight on the first hearing being right, and they cannot cure as much.

How should a body choose?

By looking at what is at stake and what the first stage looks like. Where first-instance panels are volunteer bodies with limited support, or where sanctions are severe, a rehearing, or at least a power to rehear where the appeal body considers it necessary, is the safer design. Where first-instance panels are well constituted and well supported, and the volume of appeals is high, a review with clearly stated grounds will usually do. Many bodies adopt a hybrid: a review by default, with a discretion to rehear in whole or in part. Whatever the choice, the appeal panel must be independent of the first, and the reasons given at first instance must be full enough for either model to work.

What else should the appeal rules cover?

Time limits for appealing, and whether they can be extended; whether the sanction is suspended pending appeal; whether the appeal body can increase as well as reduce a sanction; and how fresh evidence is to be dealt with. Each is a point on which silence in the rules tends to generate argument, and each is worth settling in a rules review rather than in the middle of a live case.

If you’d like help designing or reviewing an appeals procedure, see our Regulatory Compliance advisory services.